As fans gear up for Jailer 2, the familiar spectacle of Rajinikanth slipping behind tinted aviators, flicking an unlit cigarette, and dismantling armies of henchmen with slow-motion swagger is once again consuming the public imagination. For well over four decades, he has occupied an almost mythical space in Indian cinema as the invincible commercial saviour.

Yet, what modern audiences have forgotten is that long before he became the archetype of stylised mass action, Rajinikanth was one of South Indian cinema’s most nuanced and emotionally vulnerable actors.

When K. Balachander famously introduced a young Shivaji Rao Gaekwad in Apoorva Raagangal (1975), the industry did not immediately see a traditional leading man. Instead, directors saw a performer with arresting expressive intensity. Through late-1970s landmarks like Bharathiraja’s 16 Vayathinile and Balachander’s Moondru Mudichu and Avargal, Rajinikanth carved an indelible niche playing morally compromised antagonists and bitter anti-heroes whose menace was impossible to look away from.

The turning point from raw antagonist to powerhouse actor came under the visionary direction of J. Mahendran. In Mullum Malarum (1978), Rajinikanth gave what remains one of the finest naturalistic performances in Tamil cinema history as Kali, a winch operator grappling with deep affection for his sister and suffocating personal inadequacy.

Also Read: Beyond guns and battlefields: Bollywood is putting the human cost of war back on screen

That same year, in C. Rudhraiya’s parallel-cinema masterpiece Aval Appadithan, Rajinikanth stripped away all traditional heroism to play Thyagu. He followed this with S. P. Muthuraman’s Aarilirunthu Arubathu Varai (1979), a family drama where he portrayed a self-sacrificing elder brother enduring decades of ungrateful exploitation by his siblings, delivering a tragic, tear-streaked performance that earned him acclaim. Even in the early 1980s, films like Netrikkann saw him playing a complex, morally corrupt older father opposite his own son.

With the 1980 blockbuster Billa—the Tamil remake of Amitabh Bachchan’s Don—Rajinikanth discovered a sleek, urban, trench-coat-and-shades persona that ignited mass hysteria. Rajinikanth and filmmakers realised that his kinetic personal charisma could anchor a singular, larger-than-life commercial template. Hits like Murattu Kaalai, Moondru Mugam, and eventually the defining zenith of Baashha permanently established the mass-hero mantle he would carry for the rest of his career.

However, once again in 1991, he shed the saviour persona. Mani Ratnam directed him in Thalapathi, framing him as a modern-day Karna figure named Surya. Rajinikanth delivered an extraordinary balance of lethal street power and devastating emotional fragility, particularly in scenes exploring his character’s desperate longing for his abandoned mother.

Also Read: The anti-hero paradox: We root for him, but want karma to pay him back